Investing or Speculating? Check In

Investing or Speculating? Real Estate Reality Check

Before and after renovation of a residential property in Simcoe County, Ontario, illustrating real estate market changes from 2022 to 2025. Photo shared by Shannon Murree, real estate advisor with MovingSimcoe.com and RE/MAX Hallmark Chay Realty Brokerage, highlighting investing versus speculating lessons.🔥 Bought in the $800Ks. Now listed in the low $500Ks.
That’s not a typo. Let’s break it down.


The Peak Purchase

In June 2022, a buyer paid over $800,000 for a property—right at the height of the post-pandemic real estate frenzy.

Renovations followed, plus months of paying mortgage, utilities, taxes, and carrying costs—all while the property was vacant.


The 2025 Reality

Fast-forward to May 2025, and the property is now listed in the low $500,000s—a rough six-figure loss.


The Hidden Costs Many Ignore

Add to that:

✔ Renovation expenses (materials, trades, sweat equity)

✔ Vacancy or under-market rent

✔ Monthly carrying costs

✔ Wear and tear on “new” finishes—now outdated and unmarketable as such

That “flip” just flipped expectations.


Back to 2022: What Went Wrong?

Even investor-savvy agents were telling buyers to pause. Why? Because the numbers didn’t add up. CMAs (Comparative Market Analyses) lost meaning.

Pricing homes was like tossing dice and hoping they’d land in a straight line.


Not Everyone Was Willing to Play Along

Some agents refused to inflate listing prices just to win business. Others told sellers what they wanted to hear. And many buyers, driven by hype and FOMO, jumped in anyway.


Now We’re Watching It Unfold

In 2025, the consequences are clear: price drops, losses, and regret.

So the real question is:


Are You Investing… or Just Gambling?

✅ Investing means strategy, data, and clear exit plans.
✅ Speculating is emotional, reactive, and based on hope.

This isn’t fear-mongering—it’s a reality check.
Markets shift. Numbers matter. Timing alone won’t save a bad deal.


Bottom Line: Real Estate is a Business

Yes, real estate can build wealth—
but only when you treat it like a business, not a bet.

I’ve spent decades learning this the hard way—starting as an investor who made plenty of mistakes, even before becoming an agent.

If you want to avoid the pitfalls and set yourself up for real success, connect with me. Let’s talk strategy.

Share This Post: